Difference between revisions of "User talk:ClanWolverine101"
Sarna News
(response) |
|||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
I just wanted to drop you a line because I've deleted the update needed tag from [[Semier Data Tron]] for [[Objectives: Lyran Alliance]] from the article. I updated it with detail from [[Handbook: House Steiner]], but I've crawled through O:LA and I can't find any mention of the company whatsoever - although it does talk about DropShip manufacturing in the Lyran Alliance having been absolutely hammered during the Jihad. [[Jihad Turning Points: Tharkad]] indicates that the plant was encircled by Blakist divisions and then comprehensively bombarded from orbit, so I'm guessing that it's been destroyed... but I wanted to check that there wasn't something you were aware of that I'd missed that justified the update needed tag. [[User:BrokenMnemonic|BrokenMnemonic]] ([[User talk:BrokenMnemonic|talk]]) 13:46, 2 January 2013 (PST) | I just wanted to drop you a line because I've deleted the update needed tag from [[Semier Data Tron]] for [[Objectives: Lyran Alliance]] from the article. I updated it with detail from [[Handbook: House Steiner]], but I've crawled through O:LA and I can't find any mention of the company whatsoever - although it does talk about DropShip manufacturing in the Lyran Alliance having been absolutely hammered during the Jihad. [[Jihad Turning Points: Tharkad]] indicates that the plant was encircled by Blakist divisions and then comprehensively bombarded from orbit, so I'm guessing that it's been destroyed... but I wanted to check that there wasn't something you were aware of that I'd missed that justified the update needed tag. [[User:BrokenMnemonic|BrokenMnemonic]] ([[User talk:BrokenMnemonic|talk]]) 13:46, 2 January 2013 (PST) | ||
:BM - I get what you are saying. My reasoning for including that citation is this: Since SDT is not even mentioned in Objectives: Lyran Alliance, it strongly implies that it was never rebuilt, nor are there plans to do so. You'll notice throughout the Objectives series, many inactive manufacturing centers are mentioned if their reopening is even being planned. So it seemed relevant that it was absent. I'm fine with you dropping the tag. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] ([[User talk:ClanWolverine101|talk]]) 17:59, 2 January 2013 (PST) | :BM - I get what you are saying. My reasoning for including that citation is this: Since SDT is not even mentioned in Objectives: Lyran Alliance, it strongly implies that it was never rebuilt, nor are there plans to do so. You'll notice throughout the Objectives series, many inactive manufacturing centers are mentioned if their reopening is even being planned. So it seemed relevant that it was absent. I'm fine with you dropping the tag. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] ([[User talk:ClanWolverine101|talk]]) 17:59, 2 January 2013 (PST) | ||
| + | ::While I get what you're saying, I think we're on dicey ground if we start drawing conclusions from things not being mentioned in publications - in the case of Semier Data Tron, I think it'd be better to ask a question over in the Ask The Writers section if you're worried about the absence of the company being either significant or a mistake. [[User:BrokenMnemonic|BrokenMnemonic]] ([[User talk:BrokenMnemonic|talk]]) 13:52, 4 January 2013 (PST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==TharHes Industries== | ||
| + | In a similar vein to Semier Data Tron above, I've removed the tag on TharHes Industries for Masters & Minions because I can't find anything related to the company in the book, even though I searched by company name, controlling family name and went through the entries and details on the three planets the company was based on (Arc-Royal, Tharkad and Eutin Prime). If I've missed something, let me know what you were looking at and I'll go back and add the detail in. [[User:BrokenMnemonic|BrokenMnemonic]] ([[User talk:BrokenMnemonic|talk]]) 13:52, 4 January 2013 (PST) | ||
Revision as of 17:52, 4 January 2013
My own tools
- Edit Counter
- Archive Making
- Setting Up a Redirect
- External Links
- My Contributions
- Neuling's Wolf's Dragoons battles article
- Frabby's Update Needed Discussion
- Unfinished Book - JTP:New Avalon
Archives
Semier Data Tron
I just wanted to drop you a line because I've deleted the update needed tag from Semier Data Tron for Objectives: Lyran Alliance from the article. I updated it with detail from Handbook: House Steiner, but I've crawled through O:LA and I can't find any mention of the company whatsoever - although it does talk about DropShip manufacturing in the Lyran Alliance having been absolutely hammered during the Jihad. Jihad Turning Points: Tharkad indicates that the plant was encircled by Blakist divisions and then comprehensively bombarded from orbit, so I'm guessing that it's been destroyed... but I wanted to check that there wasn't something you were aware of that I'd missed that justified the update needed tag. BrokenMnemonic (talk) 13:46, 2 January 2013 (PST)
- BM - I get what you are saying. My reasoning for including that citation is this: Since SDT is not even mentioned in Objectives: Lyran Alliance, it strongly implies that it was never rebuilt, nor are there plans to do so. You'll notice throughout the Objectives series, many inactive manufacturing centers are mentioned if their reopening is even being planned. So it seemed relevant that it was absent. I'm fine with you dropping the tag. ClanWolverine101 (talk) 17:59, 2 January 2013 (PST)
- While I get what you're saying, I think we're on dicey ground if we start drawing conclusions from things not being mentioned in publications - in the case of Semier Data Tron, I think it'd be better to ask a question over in the Ask The Writers section if you're worried about the absence of the company being either significant or a mistake. BrokenMnemonic (talk) 13:52, 4 January 2013 (PST)
TharHes Industries
In a similar vein to Semier Data Tron above, I've removed the tag on TharHes Industries for Masters & Minions because I can't find anything related to the company in the book, even though I searched by company name, controlling family name and went through the entries and details on the three planets the company was based on (Arc-Royal, Tharkad and Eutin Prime). If I've missed something, let me know what you were looking at and I'll go back and add the detail in. BrokenMnemonic (talk) 13:52, 4 January 2013 (PST)